Nair Law LLC
  • Home
  • Biography
    • Rishi Nair >
      • Representative Experience
      • Publications & Awards
      • Professional & Civic Activities
      • Additional Background
  • Nair Law LLC Blog
  • Press Coverage
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer

Product liability forum non conveniens ruling favors plaintiff's choice

10/16/2013

0 Comments

 
Typically, a plaintiff chooses the most convenient place for their lawsuit and the Defendant, unless that location happens to be where they also wish, fight this choice.  Under the principle of "forum non conveniens", defendants are often successful in relocating the litigation to their home turf.  This is mainly based on the fact that the Defendant should receive whatever local benefit and efficiency because they are the ones on the hook.  In federal litigation, with diversity jurisdiction especially, early federal law sought to curb local favoritism.  In the same way, state jurisprudence has evolved to encompass a framework for evaluating where a lawsuit should be conducted.  Choice of forum is very different from choice of law, which is what law to apply. 

Here, in Taylor v. Lemans Corporation, the First Appellate District affirmed a Cook County Circuit Court decision denying Lemans' Motion to Transfer on grounds of forum non conveniens.  The facts are essential to determining the proper forum for a lawsuit.  Here, this litigation originated from a motocross accident which occurred in Bureau County, Illinois.  The plaintiff sued for product liability and chose cook county as his forum even though he did not live there.  Despite that, the Defendant's motion was denied because, as the Appellate Court reasoned, the Plaintiff's choice should be given some deference and Cook County is not inappropriately chosen despite its large caseload and distance from the accident.  Witness testimony can be obtained through depositions and computer and internet access have made the physical location of accidents less significant.

So, the intersection of technology and the law seems to shaping civil procedure and how Courts perceive the relative positions of the litigants and their ability to obtain, review, and process information. The ruling, and its supporting reasoning, indicates that Defendants need to be sharper with their forum non conveniens arguments and that they should make plans to litigate more cases in Cook County rather than collar counties (or rural western and downstate counties) because plaintiffs will undoubtedly seek to sue in Cook County because jury verdicts are viewed as more favorable to plaintiffs there than in other counties in Illinois.  

Contacting a business litigation attorney prior to litigation can help shape contracts or other materials to specify a particular favorable forum in advance of issues.  Further, once litigation is commenced, business litigation attorneys can help craft stronger, more developed arguments in favor of forum non conveniens to ensure that litigation plays out in more favorable fora to both minimize damages if there is to be an adverse ruling and to provide for better leverage in settlement negotiations after plaintiff's counsel is faced with many long commutes to litigate the case.
0 Comments

Dealership Sues Carmax For Anti-Trust Violations

5/31/2013

0 Comments

 
The MineolaAmerican reports that a local wholesale car dealership which does business with Carmax, a large consumer-oriented car reseller and purchaser, has sued the massive dealer for anti-trust violations stemming from their refusal to allow dealers to supply car history reports from any information company rather than Carmax's preferred vendor(s).

Read More
0 Comments

Martha Stewart Commercial Litigation

3/5/2013

0 Comments

 
JC Penney, Macy's, and Martha Stewart are embroiled in a large commercial breach of contract case revolving around JC Penney's capture of Martha Stewart and her Martha Stewart collection housewares.  The Chicago Tribune explains that Martha Stewart signed a contract with Macy's which obligated her to create and market a line of products in Macy's.  Macy's got Stewart, who should be very used to court proceedings, to admit in depositions that the contract also was an exclusivity contract as well as a contract for her name, fame, expertise, and line of products.

This case illustrates precisely why depositions are critical to trial and provide a clear roadmap for trial strategy for both sides.

Read More
0 Comments

Kraft Sues Cracker Barrel Over Trademark Dispute

2/1/2013

0 Comments

 
The Chicago Tribune reports that Kraft Foods, Inc. has sued casual dining chain Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Inc. and its potential retail distributor the John Morrell Food Group to enjoin and nullify their contractual attempt to licensed the trademark "Cracker Barrel" to the distributor for retail distribution.  Kraft trademarked "Cracker Barrel" in 1954 and sees Cracker Barrel Old Country Store's attempts to expand the use of their mark from their restaurant chains to retail grocers as infringing their mark.

Read More
0 Comments

Attorney Fan Sues NBA Team For Benching Top Players

1/15/2013

0 Comments

 
ESPN, of all sources, is reporting about an irate attorney who purchased a ticket to see the San Antonio Spurs play against the Miami Heat in Miami is suing the Spurs under Texas' Deceptive Trade Practices Act.  The attorney purchased a ticket for himself and his son.  Shortly before the game, the coach of the Spurs, Greg Popovich, sent their best players back to San Antonio to rest rather than play their fourth game in five nights.  The attorney is suing because he feels he was deceived into purchasing tickets and paying a premium for two teams loaded with star players.  Instead, he watched the B and C squad Spurs take the Heat to the brink in a 100-105 loss.

Read More
0 Comments

$2M Wine Negligence CLaim Filed by Insurer in Subrogation Action

11/28/2012

0 Comments

 
Stepping in the shoes of their injured insured, Great Northern Insurance Co. filed suit against Cellar Advisors, a wine moving company hired to move a portion of a wealthy family's wine collection from Illinois to Florida in climate controlled containers.  The Chicago Tribune notes that:
In June 2012, D. Gideon Searle hired St. Louis-based Cellar to transport the couple's wine collection, held in a Des Plaines warehouse, in refrigerated carriers to a Naples, Fla., wine cellar. The wine to be transported was valued at $2 million.

Read More
0 Comments

Nanny cam exposes abuse, parents sue to recover damages

10/23/2012

0 Comments

 
No loving parent can stand by without acting when their child is harmed.  No parent should have to tolerate that.  When parents hire caregivers for their children, parents, or themselves, that caregiver is entrusted with a near sacred duty to preserve the health, dignity, and vitality of a loved one.  When that duty is breached, the harm can be tremendous in both physical pain, but also emotional turmoil.

Read More
0 Comments

PROCESSED BEEF MANUFACTURER SUES ABC OVER "PINK SLIME" REPORTS

9/13/2012

0 Comments

 
Business owners need to understand how the law can protect them against competitors and insulate them from customer lawsuits.  To reinforce this lesson, consider Beef Products, Inc., a closely held South Dakota company that faced severe consequences from negative reports regarding their processed beef product.  When businesses are losing money stemming from interference with existing or future business relationships, business should contact a business attorney who can look at all of their options to remedy this threat and mitigate harm, including through litigation.

The Wall Street Journal, among others, is reporting that Beef Products Inc., , has sued ABC for defamation, tortious interference with contract (business relationship), and a state anti-food disparagement statute, among other claims.  The beef company also named Diana Sawyer, who reported on the story for ABC and microbiologist Gerald Zirnstein, who as a USDA food inspector investigating a food bacteria outbreak in 2002 toured a BPI plant and coined the term "pink slime" to describe their product.  BPI is suing these defendants for $1.20 billion, representing lost profits stemming from the alleged defamatory reporting and characterization of their product.

Read More
0 Comments

CHICAGO TEACHERS UNION STRIKE MAY BE ILLEGAL

9/12/2012

0 Comments

 
The Chicago Teachers Union is striking in Chicago right now.  The teacher's union hurdled the many procedural requirements to legally strike for wages, but recent changes to the Illinois Educational Labor Relations Act, 115 ILCS 5/1 (IELRA) may have made the strike illegal as wage demands have been met.  Below is an unofficial napkin analysis of the legal issues at play.  Since some provisions have only been effective for a bit over a year, there is no real precedent on this issue and this napkin analysis reviews the plain statutory law that governs this strike.

Read More
0 Comments

CAT SMELL OFFENDS CONDO NEIGHBORS WHO SUE ASSOCIATION AND NEIGHBOR

8/21/2012

0 Comments

 
The Chicago Tribune has reported an amusing, but common, story of neighbors who use their respective property in incompatible ways that create conflict.  According to a lawsuit filed, likely based on nuisance, breach of contract, and violations of the Condominium Property Act, 765 ILCS 605/1 et seq., a set of owners that had a condo in the building before the new owner ("Cat Lady"), have allergies to cats.  Cat Lady has allegedly accumulated 20 cats in her single bedroom condo.  The smell from the urine and feces has wafted, through shared ventilation, into the neighboring condos.  The affected condo owners have sent letters notifying both the Cat Lady and the association (and its Board) of the issue.  Even with notice, all parties failed to cure the issue and the offended parties sued.

Read More
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Author

    Rishi Nair owns Nair Law LLC and practices as Of Counsel at Keener and Associates, P.C.

    Archives

    October 2013
    September 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012

    Categories

    All
    Accident
    ADA
    Affirmative Defense
    Alienation Of Affection
    Appeal
    Association
    Award
    Bankruptcy
    Breach Of Contract
    Breach Of Warranty
    Cancellation
    Cease And Desist
    Certify
    Choice Of Forum
    Choice Of Law
    Civil Rights
    Civil Rights Act Of 1964
    Class
    Class Action
    Commerce Clause
    Common Carrier
    Common Elements
    Compliance
    Condo
    Condominium
    Constitution
    Constitutional Rights
    Contracts
    Conversion
    Countersue
    Criminal Defense
    Debt
    Debt Collector
    Deep Dish Pizza
    Defamation
    Defense
    Dilution
    Disability
    Discrimination
    Dog Bite
    Driver
    Duty Of Care
    Elements
    Employment
    Employment Litigation
    Expert
    Express Warranty
    Failure To Maintain
    Fall Protection
    FDCPA
    Federal
    Federal Law
    First Amendment
    FOIA
    Forcible Entry And Detainer Act
    Forum Non Conveniens
    Fourteenth Amendment
    Hotel
    Illinois
    Illinois Law
    Implied Warranty
    Infringement
    Injunction
    Insurance
    Intellectual Property
    Intentional Tort
    IP Litigation
    IP Litigation
    Jury
    Jury Verdict
    Lawsuit
    Litigation
    Medical Malpractice
    Negligence
    Negotiate
    Osha
    Personal Injury
    Product Liability
    Property
    Protected Conduct
    Real Estate Landlord Tenant Ordinance
    Real Property
    Reckless
    Retaliation
    RLTO
    Safety
    Second Appellate District
    Section 1983
    Seniority
    Settlement
    Seventh Circuit
    Special
    Speeding
    Sports
    Subrogation
    Tax
    Taxation
    Ticket
    Title VII
    Tort
    Tortious Interference
    Trademark
    Trademark Enforcement
    Trademark Litigation
    Trespass
    Trespass To Chattels
    TTAB
    Uniform Commercial Code
    Unpaid
    Vehicle
    Workplace Accident

    RSS Feed

    Privacy Policy
    Terms of Use
    Disclaimer


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photo used under Creative Commons from Phil Roeder