Nair Law LLC
  • Home
  • Biography
    • Rishi Nair >
      • Representative Experience
      • Publications & Awards
      • Professional & Civic Activities
      • Additional Background
  • Nair Law LLC Blog
  • Press Coverage
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer

Cautionary Tale on Commercial Dispute

1/10/2013

0 Comments

 
The Chicago Tribune reports that two brewery business partners, Isaac Showaki and Andres Araya, are engaged in litigation over a widespread dispute.  Having met 7 years ago while working for Bain Capital and consulting in Latin America for a brewer, the business partners set up a brewery in Chicago a bit less than two years.

Despite commercial success, including distribution deals with several local Chipotle franchises as well as other accolades, the business partners have a deeply personal dispute that has boiled over into the courtrooms.
According to the lawsuit filed by Araya against Showaki apparently sounds in defamation.  It alleges that Showaki told multiple people that Araya had stolen money from the brewery — including $25,000 from a recent investor — and that he had had an extra-marital affair with a former female employee.  Defamation is a cause of action that seeks compensation for harm to a person's reputation in a community.  The elements of defamation are: 
  1. (1) the defendant made a false statement about the plaintiff;
  2. (2) there was an unprivileged publication to a third party;
  3. (3) fault by the defendant amounting to at least negligence; and
  4. (4) the publication damaged the plaintiff.
Certain defamatory allegations are considered defamation per se, which means that specific monetary damages need not be proven.  They include:
  • Allegations or imputations "injurious to another in their trade, business, or profession"
  • Similarly, allegations or imputations that the person lacks integrity in his profession.
  • Allegations or imputations "of loathsome communicable disease" 
  • Allegations or imputations of "unchastity" (In Illinois this is not limited to women or unmarried individuals)
  • Allegations or imputations of adultery or fornication
Solaia Tech., LLC v. Specialty Pub'g Co., 852 N.E.2d 825, 839 (Ill. 2006).
Here, Araya is alleging that his business partner told others that he stole money, a crime and indicative that he lacks integrity in his professional capacity.  Further, it accuses him of infidelity.  Finally, these statements also are injurious to Araya's business reputation, especially since the source of the comments is his business partner.  While Araya is only suing for $25,000, it could be reasoned that his damages will exceed this sum.

Regardless, the business seems unaffected by this spat for now.  It is not unusual for business partners to have disputes.  Sometimes litigation is the answer.  Sometimes it makes more sense to hammer out these issues before they become harmful.  When it comes to defamation, like with grade school, some comments are hard to take back.  Since the bell cannot be unrung, a remedy outside of the courthouse seems useless.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Rishi Nair owns Nair Law LLC and practices as Of Counsel at Keener and Associates, P.C.

    Archives

    October 2013
    September 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012

    Categories

    All
    Accident
    ADA
    Affirmative Defense
    Alienation Of Affection
    Appeal
    Association
    Award
    Bankruptcy
    Breach Of Contract
    Breach Of Warranty
    Cancellation
    Cease And Desist
    Certify
    Choice Of Forum
    Choice Of Law
    Civil Rights
    Civil Rights Act Of 1964
    Class
    Class Action
    Commerce Clause
    Common Carrier
    Common Elements
    Compliance
    Condo
    Condominium
    Constitution
    Constitutional Rights
    Contracts
    Conversion
    Countersue
    Criminal Defense
    Debt
    Debt Collector
    Deep Dish Pizza
    Defamation
    Defense
    Dilution
    Disability
    Discrimination
    Dog Bite
    Driver
    Duty Of Care
    Elements
    Employment
    Employment Litigation
    Expert
    Express Warranty
    Failure To Maintain
    Fall Protection
    FDCPA
    Federal
    Federal Law
    First Amendment
    FOIA
    Forcible Entry And Detainer Act
    Forum Non Conveniens
    Fourteenth Amendment
    Hotel
    Illinois
    Illinois Law
    Implied Warranty
    Infringement
    Injunction
    Insurance
    Intellectual Property
    Intentional Tort
    IP Litigation
    IP Litigation
    Jury
    Jury Verdict
    Lawsuit
    Litigation
    Medical Malpractice
    Negligence
    Negotiate
    Osha
    Personal Injury
    Product Liability
    Property
    Protected Conduct
    Real Estate Landlord Tenant Ordinance
    Real Property
    Reckless
    Retaliation
    RLTO
    Safety
    Second Appellate District
    Section 1983
    Seniority
    Settlement
    Seventh Circuit
    Special
    Speeding
    Sports
    Subrogation
    Tax
    Taxation
    Ticket
    Title VII
    Tort
    Tortious Interference
    Trademark
    Trademark Enforcement
    Trademark Litigation
    Trespass
    Trespass To Chattels
    TTAB
    Uniform Commercial Code
    Unpaid
    Vehicle
    Workplace Accident

    RSS Feed

    Privacy Policy
    Terms of Use
    Disclaimer


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photo used under Creative Commons from Phil Roeder